Is the SBA corrupt? That depends on your definition. If you mean brown envelopes of cash and smoke-filled rooms, probably not. But if you mean an institution so fundamentally broken that it consistently produces outcomes opposite to its stated mission? Then yes, the SBA is corrupt to its core.
The SBA's corruption isn't the Hollywood kind. It's the insidious kind—the kind where no one person is responsible, but the system itself is designed to fail the people it's supposed to serve.
- $200 billion lost to fraud in COVID programs
- $0 clawed back from senior leadership
- 0 executives fired for the fraud disaster
- 200+ OIG recommendations ignored
- 30+ Congressional hearings with no reform
- Millions of legitimate businesses abandoned
The Seven Forms of SBA Corruption
1. Regulatory Capture
The SBA is supposed to help small businesses. In practice, it often serves the interests of large banks that participate in its loan programs. These banks lobby the SBA, staff SBA positions, and shape SBA policies. When a bank's interest conflicts with a small business owner's interest, guess who wins?
2. Bureaucratic Self-Preservation
The SBA's primary institutional goal isn't helping small businesses—it's perpetuating the SBA. Decisions are made to protect budgets, avoid blame, and maintain the status quo. If helping small businesses conflicts with bureaucratic survival, small businesses lose.
3. Metric Manipulation
The SBA measures success by loan volume and processing speed, not by business outcomes. This creates perverse incentives: approve as many loans as fast as possible, regardless of whether they help anyone. Quality is sacrificed for quantity that looks good in reports.
4. Accountability Avoidance
The SBA has perfected the art of diffusing responsibility so thoroughly that no one is ever accountable for anything. When $200 billion disappears to fraud, everyone can point to someone else. This isn't accidental—it's structural.
5. Information Asymmetry
The SBA knows things about your application that you don't. They use this information advantage to justify denials you can't effectively challenge. Transparency would expose their failures, so they maintain opacity.
6. Selective Enforcement
The SBA aggressively pursues collection from legitimate borrowers while largely failing to recover fraud. This isn't because fraud is hard to find—it's because legitimate borrowers are easier targets who can't afford to fight back.
7. Institutional Lying
The SBA routinely makes statements that are technically true but functionally lies. "Your application is being processed" when it's sitting in a queue no one will touch. "Help is available" when help is impossible to access. This systematic deception is a form of corruption.
The Revolving Door
Like many federal agencies, the SBA has a revolving door with the industries it regulates. Senior officials leave for lucrative positions at banks and financial services firms. Bank executives take SBA positions. Consultants float between government and private sector.
This creates problems:
- Officials make decisions that benefit their future employers
- Industry insiders bring industry biases into government
- Genuine reformers are outnumbered by careerists
- Institutional knowledge favors the status quo
The SBA isn't captured by one company or interest group. It's captured by a mindset—the mindset that serving small business owners is less important than serving the financial institutions that process SBA loans.
The "Pay and Chase" Decision
When COVID hit, the SBA made a deliberate choice: remove fraud controls and approve applications as fast as possible. They called this "pay and chase"—pay now, catch fraud later.
This wasn't incompetence. It was a policy decision.
They knew fraud would explode. Internal memos warned of it. The OIG warned of it. Fraud experts warned of it. They did it anyway because:
- Speed looked good politically
- High approval numbers looked like success
- Fraud would be someone else's problem later
- The officials making the decision wouldn't face consequences
This is corruption—using taxpayer money recklessly for political optics while knowing the costs would fall on others.
Who Benefits From SBA Dysfunction?
When asking "who benefits," corruption often becomes clearer:
Large Banks: They process SBA loans and collect fees. They're protected from losses by government guarantees. The riskier the loan environment, the more they depend on those guarantees.
Contractors: The SBA spends billions on technology contractors, consultants, and service providers. Many of these contracts are no-bid or poorly supervised. Failure creates more contracts to fix the failure.
Career Bureaucrats: A crisis justifies larger budgets and more staff. The bigger the disaster, the more resources flow in. No one gets fired for failure—they get additional funding to address it.
Politicians: They can claim credit for "providing relief" without accountability for how that relief is administered. The announcement is the accomplishment; the execution is someone else's problem.
Why Reform Never Happens
The SBA has been "reformed" dozens of times. Nothing changes. Here's why:
Reforms are designed by insiders. The same people who created the problems are asked to design the solutions. They protect their interests.
Reforms lack enforcement. New rules are created but not enforced. New systems are built but not used. Reform is theater.
Institutional inertia. Government agencies resist change at a fundamental level. The default behavior is always to return to the status quo.
No external pressure. Small business owners are not a powerful lobby. They don't have millions for campaign contributions. Their voices don't override institutional interests.
Short attention spans. Congress investigates, media covers, then everyone moves on. The SBA waits out the attention cycle.
Crisis → Investigation → Outrage → Hearings → Promises → Small changes → Media moves on → Return to normal → Next crisis
The Human Cost of Institutional Corruption
This isn't abstract. SBA corruption has real victims:
- Business owners denied legitimate loans while fraudsters got funded
- Retirees having Social Security garnished for loans they used correctly
- Families losing homes because their businesses couldn't survive without timely help
- Communities hollowed out when small businesses close permanently
- Workers losing jobs when employers can't access capital
Every institutional failure has a human face. The SBA's corruption isn't victimless. It's devastating millions of Americans while the responsible parties collect pensions.
What Would Real Reform Look Like?
If we actually wanted to fix the SBA:
1. Real Accountability: Senior officials should face consequences for catastrophic failures. Not reassignment—termination. Possibly prosecution.
2. Structural Separation: Separate the policy arm from the service delivery arm. Create genuine independence with different incentives.
3. Modern Technology: Gut the ancient IT systems and build new ones. Not through existing contractors—through competitive processes with performance requirements.
4. Transparency: Force the SBA to publish real-time data on applications, approvals, denials, and reasoning. Let the public see what's happening.
5. User Advocates: Create an independent ombudsman with actual power to intervene in cases and override bureaucratic decisions.
6. Fraud Prevention Design: Build systems that prevent fraud rather than chasing it after the fact. This exists in private industry—the SBA just refuses to adopt it.
Will any of this happen? Not without massive external pressure that doesn't currently exist.
Witnessed SBA Corruption?
Insider information, documented failures, personal experiences—we're collecting evidence.
Report What You Know